Former Miss

2004 Heather Clark

1999 Kelly Kratofil

1996 April Crider

1989 Dana Ernst​

1988 Sharla Dunkle

1986 Sherri Morton

1985 Paullette Stoudt

1983 Stacy Bloom

1982 Valerie Straley

1981 Anne Bathon

1980 Mary Ellis

1978 Pamela Stroop

1977 Dorothy Tasker

1974 Jody Williams

Not Pictured

Former Teen